E-cigarettes in hospitals? What do HCPs think?
Daniel Ghinn reviews the online commentary among healthcare professionals following Public Health England’s advice that smokers should be encouraged to take up vaping instead.
In February this year, Public Health England (PHE) published its annual evidence review on e-cigarettes and heated tobacco products. The report challenged public perception and policymaker communication about e-cigarettes, and recommended encouraging smokers to switch from smoking to vaping.
‘Based on current knowledge, stating that vaping is at least 95% less harmful than smoking remains a good way to communicate the large difference in relative risk unambiguously so that more smokers are encouraged to make the switch from smoking to vaping’, reads the report’s executive summary, which goes on to point out that ‘It should be noted that this does not mean e-cigarettes are safe’.
The report caused an immediate stir among the online community of healthcare professionals (HCPs) in the UK and internationally, with opinions divided about the wisdom of encouraging e-cigarette use over other approaches to smoking cessation.
The mood of HCPs on the day was well expressed in a Tweet posted by West Yorkshire-based public health registrar, Caroline Tomes, who pointed out that public health professionals are divided on the subject of e-cigarettes.
Discussions around e-cigarettes fascinate me. Public health professionals are united on many fronts – but so incredibly divided when it comes to e-cigs.
— Caroline Tomes (@carotomes) February 7, 2018
Cancer Research UK followed PHE’s report with a blog post summarising the findings and concluding that “smokers should take note that if they’ve tried everything else to move away from tobacco, evidence points towards e-cigarettes being a less harmful alternative,” but accepted that “There are still some outstanding questions that only long-term data can answer.”
When PHE tweeted Cancer Research UK’s post, Heather Gallagher, Associate Director of Midwifery in Northampton, was one of several HCPs who shared it.
— PublicHealthEngland (@PHE_uk) February 7, 2018
Although not all agreed with PHE’s position, many HCPs welcomed the PHE’s commentary and recommendations on e-cigarettes. Trudi Grant, Director of Public Health for Somerset, UK, shared a Tweet posted by the Royal Society for Public Health celebrating PHE’s content as “fantastic evidence-based debunking of some of the big misconceptions around #ecigs.”
PHE and Cancer Research UK were not the only public health influencers that sparked discussion among the online community. Northumbria NHS Trust had already been working towards implementing an entirely smoke-free environment from 1 April 2018, with smoking not permitted in any of its hospitals, community sites or grounds across Northumberland and North Tyneside, and taking down its former smoking shelters.
On the day of its switch to smoke-free, the Trust tweeted a clarification about e-cigarettes, which – unlike cigarettes – it does allow on its grounds.
E-cigarettes are permitted on our grounds, but not permitted indoors.
E-cigarettes don’t contain tobacco, so the user is not exposed to poisonous gases that are in tobacco smoke and are reported to be up to 95% less harmful than cigarettes.https://t.co/tmCbnEiQIc#Smokefree pic.twitter.com/vOtSZIi1th
— NorthumbriaNHS (@NorthumbriaNHS) March 31, 2018
Among those who shared the Trust’s tweet was its Lead Cancer Nurse, Amanda Walshe.
While Northumbria NHS Trust made its policy on e-cigarettes clear, other trusts were prompted to develop a position. In Scotland, several HCPs shared NHS Grampian’s Tweet asking for feedback on whether to allow e-cigarettes on its grounds.
.@NHSGrampian would like to gather people’s views on whether they think that e-cigarette use (vaping) should be allowed on NHS Grampian grounds.
✅News release: https://t.co/IvcMZfUOqV
✅Direct link to the survey: https://t.co/r30wJKkEaL
The survey closes on Wednesday 14 March pic.twitter.com/K6CGBnIhBt
— NHS Grampian (@NHSGrampian) February 22, 2018
PHE reflected on hospital policy in an explanatory post on its Public Health Matters blog, published the same day in February that its report was published, in which it said that “…many hospitals in the UK now allow ECs in some areas, whereas smoking is banned.”
Sparking international debate among HCPs
If HCPs were somewhat divided by PHE’s advice to promote e-cigarettes, it was the policymaker’s recommendation that the products should be made available in hospital shops that was especially controversial and drew significant debate at an international level.
“…all smokers including staff and visitors should be able to buy a choice of stop smoking aids (which could include EC) from the hospital shop”, wrote PHE in its blog.
In Belgium, Wouter Arrazola de Oñate, a medical doctor who works with the Belgian Lung and Tuberculosis Association, joined an online conversation in which he tweeted his view that PHE does not have a good reputation when it comes to advice on electronic cigarettes, adding that PHE’s report is full of assumptions.
In the US, Stanton Glantz, professor and tobacco control activist, tweeted a study which he said challenged PHE’s recommendation that e-cigarettes should be used in hospitals. His Tweet was shared by many HCPs among the international community in the US and Europe.
E-cigarette users in Europe (including England) are less likely to quit smoking conventional cigarettes: Results challenge PHE recommendation that e-cigarettes be used in hospitals https://t.co/eDeQUDJBQ9
— Stanton Glantz (@ProfGlantz) February 12, 2018
More recently, as new research continues to emerge, HCPs reacted to research published in the Pharmaceutical Journal claiming that e-cigarettes could hinder smoking cessation in some groups. Sharing the article, Dave Bareham, a respiratory specialist physiotherapist, expressed his view in a Tweet that PHE’s position was extraordinary.
Yet further evidence demonstrating the weak and tenuous evidence that e-cigarettes are effective for tobacco smoking cessation https://t.co/DO4x42gGjG and yet, RCP, PHE and ASH advises they are promoted widely as quitting aids. Extraordinary . . . @martinmckee @SimonCapewell99
— Dave Bareham (@BarehamDave) April 4, 2018
One thing that most HCP commentators agree on, together with PHE and Cancer Research UK, is that the evidence is still developing. This is reflected in PHE’s report, which states repeatedly that there is a need for continued research. As long-term data emerges, the voice of HCPs on the front lines of public health will continue to provide a rich source of insight.
About the author:
Daniel Ghinn is Founder and CEO of HCP insights consultancy CREATION, leading the team working with healthcare brands. He tweets at @creationdaniel.